This article reviews several studies on sexing bones and teeth by discriminant function method which particularly concern with the modern Japanese samples.
Since PONS (1955) applied this method on human femur and sternum, investigators in the fields of physical anthropology and forensic medicine have come to recognize its usefulness for sexing, and a good number of studies have been undertaken.
Using Japanese samples, HANIHARA first reported discriminant function coefficients for sexing long bones in 1958, and since then, several studies on the Japanese bones and teeth have been published.
In this article, the author reviewed historical background of this method, explained statistical procedures for calculating discriminant function coefficients by direct as well as stepwise methods and reliability of individual discriminant function value, and discussed differences in coefficients and effectiveness of the functions between different populations. On the basis of experiences of the author, the following points were suggested for sexing bones and teeth effectively by the discriminant function method:
1) The sexing is highly reliable when a probability of a given sample being a male or a female, P(Gκ/y) on page 405, is equal to or greater than 0.7;
2) Authors who intend to publish papers related to this problem are recommended to provide all the raw data of the samples used, or at least those statistics which are required for calculating the above mentioned probability such as mean discriminant function values for male and female groups and a pooled variance or standard deviation of the function values;
3) The number of samples for each group is recommended to be 50 or more which allow to obtain a reliable covariance matrix needed for computing the discriminant function coefficients.
The author also showed an illustrative example of calculation of P(Gκy) using mean discriminant function values (yM and yF) and their pooled standard deviation (6). Finally the discriminant function coefficients, sectioning points and effectiveness of each discriminant function for the Japanese samples were shown in tables 1 through 9. In addition, table 10 gives statistical values for calculating P(Gκ/y), which were obtained from the raw data on the Japanese skulls and teeth provided by HANIHARA and KoizuMi (1979) and TANAKA et al. (1979).
View full abstract