The purpose of this study was to investigate the accuracy of estimating human body composition changes using bioelectrical impedance (BI) methods during a weight-loss intervention. Subjects were forty-three obese men (age : 49.2±10.5 yr, BMI : 27.8±1.7 kg/m
2) who completed a 14-week weight-loss intervention. In all subjects, fat mass (FM) and fat-free mass (FFM) were assessed by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) as well as single- and multi-frequency BI methods (SBIM, MBIM) before and after the intervention. Resistance parameters were measured by SBIM and MBIM (SBIM : R
50 ; MBIM : R∞, R0, and Rfc). In nine subjects these variables were also measured at weeks 1 and 4. Weight decreased (P<0.05) by -8.0±3.2 kg during the intervention while FFM changes averaged -0.4±1.6 kg (DXA), -2.0±1.5 kg (SBIM), and -1.6±1.7 kg (MBIM). BI methods overestimated FFM before the intervention (before ; DXA : 54.4±4.8 kg, SBIM : 56.5±4.3 kg, MBIM : 55.9±4.5 kg). In nine subjects, FFM measured by SBIM (FFM
SBIM) and MBIM (FFM
MBIM) was similar to FFM measured by DXA(FFM
DXA)(after ; DXA : 54.6±5.4 kg, SBIM : 54.6±3.8 kg, MBIM : 54.6±4.1 kg), although BI methods overestimated the FFM before the intervention (before ; DXA : 54.9±5.1 kg, SBIM : 56.9±3.8 kg, MBIM : 56.3±4.4 kg). The ΔFM
SBIM and ΔFM
MBIM were highly correlated with the ΔFM
DXA(SBIM : r=0.87, MBIM : r=0.88). The ΔFFM
SBIM andΔFFM
MBIM were significantly correlated with the ΔFFM
DXA(SBIM : r=0.54, MBIM : r=0.49). The ΔR
50 and ΔRfc were also significantly correlated with the ΔFFM
DXA(R
50 : r=-0.63, Rfc : r=-0.48). These results suggest that during a weight-loss intervention, 1) BI methods and DXA provide similar estimates of human body composition change, although they overestimate FFM in obese men, and 2) changes of resistance parameters observed with BI methods may estimate human body composition change more accurately.
View full abstract