The reliability of the piperacillin (PIPC) disc susceptibility test in estimating approximate values of MICs was studied with various clinical isolates totaling 284 strains using Showa discs and the discs prepared in this laboratory (both 8 mm diameter containing 30 μg of PIPC).
Clinical significance of a 4 category system for the interpretation of the PIPC disc tests, which iswidely used in Japan, was reevaluated to determine whether this system would be suitable or not for the evaluation of proper dose levels of administration. Break points in MIC values proposed for the classification of bacteria into 4 categories of susceptibility were: (+++) MIC< 3, μg/ml,(++) MIC > 3-15 μg/ml,(+) MIC>15-60μg/ml,(-) MIC>60μg/ml. A 3 category system for interpreting of disctest, which is generally used in the USA and Europe, was also evaluated. MIC break points in the 3 category system proposed for the classification of the PIPC test are sensitive (S) MIC < 64 μg/ml and resistant (R) MIC >256, μg/ml. In addition, British Society for Antimicrobial Chemotherpy recently proposed
in vitro MIC break points for PIPC in therapeutic use, recommending MICs 16 and 64 μg/ml.MIC 16 μg/ml can be used for general infections treated with usual administrative doses for such infections and MIC 64 μg/ml may apply to increased dosage or to normal dosage when PIPC is locally concentrated (mainly urinary or biliary tract infections).
The results obtained with the disc method were compared with MICs determined using the agar dilution method at an inoculum level of 10
6 CFU/ml. The results of the PIPC disc susceptibility test either with Showa discs or discs prepared in this laboratory were well correlated with MICs, showing the reliability of the disc method in estimating approximate values of MICs.
In the 4 category classification system of the Showa disc test, 33 out of 284 strains (11.6%) tested showed false positive results and 5 strains (1.8%) false negative results. Similarly, in the test of 30 μg discs prepared in this laboratory, of 284 strains 26 (9.2%) showed false positive results and 8 (2.8%) false negative results.
In the tests of Showa discs and discs prepared in this laboratory, both containing 30 μg of PIPC, no inhibitory zones were observed against the strains with MIC > 100, ug/ml. Therefore, using these 30 μg discs it is impossible to classify bacteria into 3 categories of (S) MIC < 64 ug/ml,(I) MIC > 64-<256μg/ml, and (R) MIC > 256μg/ml.
However, it is possible to classify bacteria into 3 categories using the criteria proposed by the British Society for Antimicrobial Chemotherapy. In this system, false positive and false negative results in the Showa disc test were 21 out of 284 strains (7.4%) and 3 strains (1.1%), respectively. Those in the tests with discs prepared in this laboratory were 18 out of 284 strains (6.3%) and 4 strains (1.4%), respectively.
Antimicrobial activities of PIPC against various clinical isolates obtained in 1988 were as follows:
Staphylococcus aureus and
Staphylococcus epidermidis inhibited by PIPC at 12.5 μg/ml were 43.3 and 72.4% of the strains tested, respectively and
Enterococcus faecalis thus inhibited was 93.3%. Similarly,
Escherichia coli,
Klebsiella pneumoniae, indole negative and indole positive
Proteus spp. inhibited at 12.5μg/ml were 71, 90,100 and 100% of the strains, respectively. Those of
Pseudomonas aeruginosa,
Serratia spp.,
Enterobacter spp. and
Citrobacter spp. were 70, 81.3, 65.5 and 68.8% of the strains, respectively. At a dose level of 50 μg/ml of PIPC, 73.3-100% of various clinical isolates were inhibited except
S. aureus of which only 43.3% was inhibited.
View full abstract