Toxin detection from stool specimens is prerequisite for
Clostridium difficile-associated diarrhea and colitis. However, in Japan only one toxin detection kit is commercially available, which requires computerized VIDAS
® fluorescence reader. In this study we evaluated ImmunoCard Toxin A
®, which is an enzyme immunoassay with a format of individual cassetteand needs no special equipment to perform, by comparing with the VIDAS CDA
® kit. Of 61 stoolspecimens 12 were positive and 39 were negative by both assays, 7 were VIDAS
® positive-ImmunoCard
® negative, 2 were VIDAS
® invalid-ImmunoCard
® negative, and 1 was invalid by both assays. Stool specimens which gave inconsistent results between two assays were subjected to cellculture assay to detect toxin B and culture for
C. difficile followed by testing of toxin producibility of isolates. Of 7 VIDAS
® positive-ImmunoCard
® negative specimens 5 were negative for cell culture assay and toxigenic
C. difficile culture and 2 were positive for cell culture assay. By omitting 3 VIDAS
® invalid specimens and counting 5 specimens, which were cell culture negative but VIDAS
® positive, as negative and 2, which were cell culture posotive and VIDAS
® positive, as positive, 12 of the 14 VIDAS
® positive specimens were ImmunoCard
® positive (sensitivity, 85.7%) and all 44 VIDAS
® negative were ImmunoCard
® negative (specificity, 100%). These results indicate that although in comparison with VIDAS CDA
®, Immuno-Card Toxin A
® is slightly less sensitive, ImmunoCard
® is a rapid, simple, and reliable
C. difficile toxin A detection kit, which has the advantage of requiring no special equipment to perform and no centrifuge step, as small as 25μL, L of a specimen, and as short as approximately 15 min of time to complete the whole testing.
View full abstract