In an attempt to study the incidence of injuries to the base of the skull during nasal surgery, a total of 1, 166 questionnaires were sent to the members of the Japan Rhinologic Society.
Three hundred and sixty-seven questionnaires returned. The tally of the sinus operations performed by the above doctors was approximately 450, 000.
The exposures of the dura mater during the operations amounted 668 in the series. The rate of exposure of the dura mater during sinus surgery was, therefore, one in every 680 operations.
The rate of occurrence of CSF leakage during sinus operation turned out to be one in every 3, 000 operations and the rate of development of acute meningitis due to injury to the dura mater was one in every 8, 800 operations.
The mortality rate due to acute meningitis after sinusectomy was found to be one in every 30, 000 operations.
A more detailed questionnaire was sent to 107 rhinologists who encountered injury to the base of the skull during surgery in order to study various factors which were responsible for the development of the side injuries.
Forty-eight different factors were surveyed in the second questionnaire and the results were subjected to a computor analysis to evaluate each factor for the development of the complications.
Some of the results obtained include ;
1. Injury to the base of the skull is more likely to occur in young patients than in elderly subjects.
2. Intranasal approach showed a little higher incidence of side injury than in permaxillary approach.
3. Exposure of the dura mater occurs mainly at the roof of the ethmoid sinus.
4. Seventy-five percent of the injuries to the base of the skull were inflicted either by cup forceps or a curet.
5. Eighty percent of intracranial complications after dural injury were developed from a relatively small' dural injury which was less than 3 mm in diameter.
6. The rate of incidence of meningitis after dural injury was highest at the cribriform plate, followed by the posterior ethmoid sinus and then by the anterior ethmoid sinus.
7. Of a total of 107 cases with exposure of the dura mater during intranasal surgery, 19 cases or 17.8% developed intracranial complication and 4 cases of the 19 died of the intracranial complication.
The mortality rate due to acute meningitis appears to be quite high. Although this is partly due to the fact that this series includes cases in the pre-antibiotic era, the intracranial complication due to nasal surgery is considered to be of grave consequence even today.
View full abstract