The methacholine aerosol provocation test through the nose by Astograph acts as mild irritation for the nasal mucosa. Therefore, this test is considered to have examined the original state of the reaction of the nasal mucosa. However, it is thought that the dose-response curve applies to both the upper and lower airways, as methacholine aerosol is inhaled into the lower airway. Accordingly, the evaluation of the reaction of the nasal mucosa alone must be divided into the upper and lower airways.
We examined three methods : the subtraction method, the L & P method, and the standard method. In the subtraction method, a value indicating respiratory resistance through the mouth is subtracted from a value indicating respiratory resistance through the nose. The L & P method provides a value calculated based on the equation created by Lacourt and Polger. The standard method provides a value indicating anterior rhinomanometry.
Conclusions : 1) The subtraction method was found to have the highest sensitivity of all methods tested for the methacholine aerosol provocation test through the nose, but this method was not able to completely eliminate the influence of the lower airway. 2) The L & P method can be used to divide the upper and lower airways, but this method needed a complicated count and was found to be less sensitive than the other two methods. 3) The standard method requires an additional rhinomanometer unit. However, the sensitivity of this method for the provocation test was found to be good. This method was considered most suitable for the evaluation of the reaction of the nasal mucosa alone.
View full abstract