This paper explores how intimacy and its meaning are transformed as a society modernizes. According to the previous studies, as a society modernized, reflexive intimacy (i.e., intimacy independent of, or disembedded out of, specific conditions or extrinsic criteria, e.g., friendship outside of kinship, neighborhood, or workplace) was popularized and became important to some degree for individuals. However, the untested hypotheses were as follows: As a society modernizes, (1)"the number or proportion of reflexive intimacy changes," (2)"the importance of reflexive intimacy increases," and (3)"the importance of reflexive intimacy does not increase necessarily but can decrease or stop increasing after reaching some degree without reaching the ceiling (i.e., intimacy reembedded into extrinsic criteria also becomes important)." As a test method, a country-individual multilevel analysis was necessary. Thus, it was adopted here.
First, multilevel analyses of "the number and proportion of reflexively selected friends" were conducted by using the data of the International Social Survey Programme 2001. The results showed that a country-level modernization variable (school enrollment rate) was effective (Analysis I).
Second, an analysis of "the contribution to happiness (or the general importance)of reflexive friendship" was conducted by using the same ISSP 2001 data. The result showed that as a country-level modernization variable (GDP per capita) increased, general importance of reflexive friendship decreased (Analysis II).
Third, an analysis of "the ratio of the importance of friends (more reflexive intimacy)to that of family (less reflexive intimacy)" was conducted by using the data of the World Values Survey 1990 and 2000. The result showed that as GDP per capita increased, the relative importance of friends stopped increasing after reaching a certain degree below the ceiling (Analysis III).
The result of Analysis I supported Hypothesis (1), and the results of Analyses II and III both supported Hypothesis (3) more than Hypothesis (2).
View full abstract