We have been tackling for many years the etiological problems of rheumatic fever mainly from the standpoint of Host-Parasite relationship. Terawaki, one of the authors, previously published a part of the studies in this magazine (Vol 42 No 3, June 1968) in which reproduction of human rheumatic fever was attempted on monkeys by the use of Streptococcus hemolyticus (S.H.) group A type 12. He obtained some evidence of hope in it. However, it was by no means considered fully satisfactory.
After some preliminary experiments to reassess the suitability of experimental animals as the hosts and injecting materials as antigens or stressors, we decided this time to use the same species of monkey as above of 2.5 to 3.0 Kg body weight and adopt two types of group A S.H., type 12 and type5, in the form of live organisms, M protein fraction and lipopolysaccharide extracts. LD50 of live S.H. suspension fluid was 0.25 to 0.35 mg to dd-mice of 20 gm. M protein was prepared by Lancefield's method, and lipopolysaccharide by Westphal's method. In the case of M protein and lipopolysaccharide experiments, we combined the use of Antigen-Antibody-Complex prepared by Ouchterlony method in the final phase of the experiments. In some groups of the animals, we sensitized them with the cow serum in advance.
The period of experiments were mostly within from January 1968 to March 1969. The intervals of every injections varied from 3-5 days, one, two, four weeks to one month. Amount of the injecting materials varied from 1-5 mg to relatively large amount, 30-50 mg, at one time.
The animals were divided into 12 categories according to administration mode and the kind of injecting materials, which are briefly summarized as follows:
1) Live S.H. administration (i.v.) to cow-serum-sensitized monkeys (type 12 to 3 monkeys (1), type 5 to 3 monkeys (2)).
2) Live S.H. (s.c.)(type 12 to 2 monkeys (3), type 5 to 2 monkeys (4), alternate use of type 12 and 5 to 2 monkeys (5)).
3) Intra-tonsillar injection of live S.H. (type 12 to one monkey (6), type 5 to one monkey (7), alternate use to 2 monkeys (8)).
4) M protein mixed with Freund's complete or incomplete adjuvant (combination of s.c., i.m. and i.v.) combined with Antigen-Antibody-Complex (intra-myocard or s.c.)(type 12 to 4 monkeys (9), type 5 to 4 monkeys (10)).
5) Lipopolysaccharide extracts mixed with Freund's complete or incomplete adjuvant (combination of s.c., i.m. and i.v.) combined with Antigen-Antibody-Complex (intra-myocard or s.c.)(type 12 to 4 monkeys (11), type 5 to one monkey (12)).
6) Two monkeys were used as contrast.
With all the cases, the following symptoms and data were checked: fever, joint swelling, limping, cardiac murmur, PCG, ECG, sludge phenomenon of the blood and eye grounds vessels, chest X-ray, ASL-0, total protein and r-globulin level, complement value of the serum and anti-myocard antibody level.
Conclusively, several cases with prolonged live S.H. injections, type 12 or 5, were found much more resembling to human rheumatic fever in their symptoms and data than those of the previous experiments. And, in one case with M protein and Antigen-Antibody-Complex injections, we believe that we could reproduce clinically strikingly identical findings to human rheumatic fever in the animal. It thereby demonstrated fever, positive sludge phenomenon and most importantly the apical systolic murmur both in auscultation and PCG just characteristic of mitral insufficiency of human rheumatic carditis. Altogether with the fact that it was given the component of S. H., the changes are in agreement with revised Jones Criteria (1965) for human rheumatic fever.
Additionally, based on our data, several hypothesis concerning the development of rheumatic carditis and M protein were rendered in this paper.
View full abstract