Objective : We studied the usefulness of clinical neurophysiological findings, especially, somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) for differential diagnosis of multiple system atrophy (MSA) including striatonigral degeneration (SND) and olivopontocerebellar atrophy (OPCA) with Parkinson's disease (PD) as well as the clinical aspects and neuroimagings.
Patients : Fifty-four patients diagnosed as having SND (14 cases), OPCA (9 cases), PD (18 cases) were studied along with disease contols (13 cases).
Methods : We compared the clinical features, brain MRI findings and SEPs obtained by median nerve stimulation among 4 groups ; SND, OPCA, PD and disease controls.
Results : We could not find any significant differences in age at disease onset among SND, OPCA and PD patients. The degree of disease progression in SND and OPCA was faster than that in PD. Myoclonus was recognized much more frequently in SND (36%) compared with OPCA (22%) and PD (6%). In clinical neurophysiological study, the mean of the amplitudes of N
20-P
25 in SND was significantly larger than that in OPCA, while the amplitudes in SND tended tobe slightly larger than those in PD. The mean of the amplitudes of P
25-N
33 in SND was significantly larger than that in PD. Furthermore, the mean of both N
20-P
25 and P
25-N
33 in SND was significantly larger than those in OPCA and PD. In patients with SND with myoclonus, we found premovement cortical spike in three of the four patients examined.
Conclusion : From comparative studies of clinical, brain MRI and clinical neurophysiological findings, we found that myoclonus in SND was significantly more frequent than that in PD, and that the amplitudes of cortical parts of SEP (N
20-P
25 or P
25-N
33) in SND were larger than those in OPCA or PD. From the results of C reflex and jerk-locked back averaging triggered with myoclonus, the myoclonus recognized in SND was considered cortical reflex myoclonus.
From these findings, SEP study would be useful method for differential diagnosis of SND from PD or OPCA.
View full abstract