The development of specific chemotherapeutic agents revolutionally improved theprognosis of tuberculosis and markedly shortened the duration of the treatment. Evidenceof successful treatment with short-course regimens for pulmonary tuberculosis has beenaccumulated. But, the duration of hospitalization tends to be determined empirically andvarys among hospitals and clinicians. Generally speaking, the duration of hospitalization islonger in Japan than in the United States and Europian countries.
We investigated retrospectively the duration of hospitalization, treatment period, andrecurrence rate of the disease for patients with pulmonary tuberculosis who admitted to the Tokyo Metropolitan Fuchu Hospital in the years 1984, 1988, and 1991.
Patients who had been previously treated for more than 2 weeks and/or, had severecomplications, such as malignancy and miliary tuberculosis were excluded from the study.
Cases who died during the hospitalization and discharged without permission were alsoexcluded.
Numbers of subjects in each year were 114, 114, and 115 in 1984, 1988, and 1991, respectively. A total of 343 patients (M; 254, F; 89) were enrolled to the study and theiraverage age was 49.4 yrold. A number of patients with both smear and culture positive insputum bacteriology was 210 (61.2%), and 42 cases (12.2%) were smear negative and culturepositive.
The results are as follows:
(1) Mean duration of hospitalization in the years 1984, 1988, and 1991 were 141, 102, and 72 days, respectively. That is, a mean hospitalization period was shortened to abouthalf during these seven years.
(2) According to the chest x-ray classification (Group A; I, II3, B; II 1, II2, III3, C; III1, III 2), mean durations of hospitalization were 186 days for group A, 143 days forgroup B, and 108 days for group C in 1984, and 96 days, 76 days, and 59 days in 1991, respectively.
(3) According to sputum bacteriology, mean durations of hospitalization were 169 daysfor (S+/C+) cases, 105 days for (S-/C+) cases, and 90 days for (S-/C-) cases in 1984, and 83 days, 67 days, and 41 days in 1991, respectively.
(4) Mean duration of treatment was also shortened by years. The difference oftreatment periods among groups classified by X-ray findings was relatively small incomparison with that of hospitalization periods.
(5) Of 220 cases who completed treatment and were subsequently followed in ourhospital, 52 cases were followed for less than six months, 47 cases for 6-12 months, and 121cases over one year after the end of treatment. During these observation periods, relapsehas occurred in two patients. In addition to these relapse cases, one patient turned to bebacteriologically positive in sputum again during treatment and the one more patient withorganisms resistant to both isoniazid and rifampicin did not become sputum negativedespite of the treatment.
The principal aims of hospitalization for patients with pulmonary tuberculosis areinduction of intense chemotherapy and treatment for complications. On the basis of the lowfrequency of multi-drug resistant case, we concluded that the duration of hospitalizationcould be shortened for the patients who have no history of previous treatment and havegood compliance to current regimen.
View full abstract