We investigated the reliability of patient-generated data from self-monitoring of blood glucose (SMBG) in 17 patients with insulin-treated diabetes mellitus by means of a memory-reflectance meter with a storage capacity for blood glucose measurements with corresponding time and date.
The patients were not aware of the memory capacity and were instructed to continue their practice of recording blood glucose diaries. In order to assess the reliability of patient-generated data as recorded in the blood glucose diaries, all omissions, additions and alterations of test values were determined. The precision index, which is the percent of values identified in blood glucose diaries, and the in memory-reflectance meter correspondance was 71.8±32.3%(Mean±SD). The omission index, which is the rate of underreporting of SMBG measurements from blood glucose diaries, was 24.8±24.2%. The addition index, which is the overreporting rate of phantom values from blood glucose diaries, was 19.3±27.8%. These indices showed that there were false self-reported SMBG data
After the use of a memory-equipped reflectance meter was brought the patient's attention, the precision index was 97.6±5.5%, the omission index was 2.6±3.7%, and the addition index was 2.3±6.6%. That is, the reliability of self-reported SMBG data was significantly improved, and HbA1c and serum fructosamine levels were significantly decreased.
In an analysis of precision and omission indices insulin-treated diabetic patients were found to have changed unacceptable values to acceptable values or omitted unacceptable values in hypo-or hyperglycemic results. However in the addition index not only acceptable values but also unacceptably hyperglycemic values were added to the blood glucose diaries in type A, type C and type D, as confirmed by the Yatabe-Guilford personality (Y-G) test of diabetic patients.
These observations indicate that while there were many false self-reported SMBG data which were unacceptably hypo-or hyperglycemic values, the patient's knowledge of the use of a memory-equipped reflectance meter would decrease the amount of false self-reported data.
View full abstract