The Glycohemoglobin (GHb) Standardization Committee conducted the fifth external quality assessment to evaluate the interlaboratory variation of GHb values measured by various methods including HPLC, various kinds of immunoassay (IMA) and affinity chromatographic methods in 1, 901 institutes throughout the country using four samples {2 concentrated whole blood (M·A·P, Nisseki) and 2 lyophilized hemolysate}.
We got the following results,
1) The CVs as indices of the interlaboratory variation ranged from 4.5 to 5.7% when all data were combined. It was different depending on an analytical method used:HPLC, 3.1-4.8%; IMA, 5.2-6.4%; Affinity, 5.2-6.0%.
2) The means of the measured values were different depending on a method used. The value measured by the affinity chromatographic method was significantly higher than the others.
The CVs of all values except for those measured by the affinity chromatographic method ranged from 4.4 to 5.4%, which were good enough from a clinical point of view.
3) The CVs of the GHb values corrected with the assigned values of a new calibrator candidate were much smaller than those without correction, except for that obtained by the affinity chromato graphicmethod. The new calibrator candidate appeared not to be suitable for correction of the values measured by the affinity method.
4) Percent distributions of participants classified by the upper value of their reference interval for GHb were as follows:≤5.8%, 77.6%; 5.9-6.0%, 14.7% and ≥6.1%, 7.7%.
In conclusion, the interlaboratory difference in GHb measurement was reduced to a clinically permissible level.
View full abstract