The present study was designed to elucidate whether or not the effectiveness of three problem-solving styles (problem-formation style, problem-selection style, guided-discovery style) differ with children's attitudes toward physical education teaching and motor skills among 5th and 6th graders in elementary school. Three teaching materials (running-broad jump, hurdle running and unastride vault on a vaulting horse) were chosen for their use of 'closed skills'. According to the diagnostic results based on the attitude scores, eight cases rated 'successful class' were chosen as the subjects. Then, the attitudes were measured before and after each unit of instruction, respectively, using Kobayashi Physical Education Inventory. The motor skills were evaluated by the change during, before and after unit instruction with the relationships between 'run- up speed' and 'jumping distance' in the cases of running-broad jump and between 'time of 50m hurdle running' and '50m flat time' in the cases of hurdle running, respectively. And the exercise of the vault horse was evaluated by the ratio of successful trial which is defined by jumping over 80cm high. The effects of the above three problem-solving styles on the children's attitudes and motor skills were investigated and the effects were found to help develop attitudes and motor skills in the order of problem-formation style followed by guided-discovery and problem-selection. These results might be explained as follows; exercise teaching materials are based on the thought that they should be organized by children and not by teachers who pick them up from the cultural realm, in the problem-formation learning. It was considered that such thought might be a methodological principle of problem-solution leaning which brings about voluntary and independent learning. In addition, it was suggested that for the exercise of 'closed skills', in which the order of motor-learning phases is very important, there are not a few difficulties in the use of method by problem-selection style.
View full abstract