We have been reporting on the cytologic diagnosis of ascites at this Society and the Society of the clinical pathology. At this time, we investigated pleural fluid by cytodiagnostic technics. As a rule, the mesothelial cell and phagocytes which appear most commonly in pleural fluid are negative for mucus stain, while some of the carcinomatous cells are positive. Therefore, like in the cytologic examination of ascites, PAS stain and alcianblue stain were combined with HE and papanicolaou original stain.
Most of the cases, from which the pleural fluid materials were taken during their lifetime were autopsied and their primary lesions were confirmed.
Of the 30 cases studied, 11 cases were pulmonary, 4 were gastric, 4 breast, 4 ovarial, 3 intestinal, 1 pancreatic, 1 gallbladder carcinoma and 2 inflammatory pleurisy. In the control materials, mucous stain was negative. Of 28 materials obtained from carcinomatous. pleurisy, 32.0% were postive for mucous stain.
The stain was positive in 27.2% of the cases with pulmonary carcinoma, the most corn non cause of carcinomatous pleural effusion. In the previously performed similar study on the ascites of carcinomatous peritonitis, the mucus stain was positive in 13 cases (35.1%) of the 37 cases, and the rate went up to 48% in the case of gastric carcinoma, that is the most common cause of carcinomatous peritonitis. Thus the rate of positive stain in the carcinomatous pleural effusion was lower than that in the carcinomatous ascites. Among the mucous stains used for cytodiagnosis, PAS stain was the most reliable.
With this stain, however, glycogen is also stained, and hence its differentiation from mucus is necessary. The differentiation can be made in some extent, since mucus is stained like droplet and glycogen like glanula. However, the differentiation of mucus from other polysaccharides becomes difficult if the PAS stain is too strong, and thus one should pay attentionn to the strength of the stain.
In a cytologic diagnosis of pleural fluid, one is often encountered with those cells which should be classified as grade III.
In such occasion, one may diagnose it as a carcinomatous cell if it is positive for mucus. stain.
Therefore, the mucus stain should be performed as a routine.
View full abstract