Insuin-hypoglycemia and arginine monochloride infusion are potent stimuli for the secretion of growth hormone (GH) from the pituitary. It has been supposed, however, that these two stimuli may act on different sites in the GH stimulatory system, because of the difference in the effect of glucose or corticosteroids, and in the overlapping effect on other pituitary hormones of these stimuli. Should this be so, some cases of dissociation in the responses to these stimuli could be expected in a mass of clinical cases.
Fifty-nine patients with various conditions were studied with both stimulatory tests. Each test was performed after overnight fasting and bed rest. In the arginine test, arginine monochloride, 0.5 g/kg body weight in 10% solution, was infused for over 30 minutes. Regular insulin, 0.1 U/kg body weight, was injected as a single shot in the insulin test. In each test, blood was take every 30 minutes for 150 minutes from 30 minutes before the injection or the beginning of the infusion.
Plasma GH levels were determined by double-antibody radioimmunoassay with NIH-GH-HS1147BC as standard. All results were neglected when the basal GH level was over 5 ng/ml in each test or the blood sugar nadir was over 50 mg/100 ml in insulin test.
In 34 healthy subjects, the mean peak plasma GH level in the arginine test was 19.8 ng/ml with a two-standard deviation (2σ) range of 9.6-40.9 and that for insulin test in 30 cases was 26.6 with a 2σ-range of 11.8-59.7 (calculated by logarithmic conversion; Figure 1). Responses with peak values below 2a-limit were considered to be lower than normal. The reproducibility of these two tests was shown to be fairly good (Figures 2 and 3).
The results are summarized in Figure 4.
Eleven cases with primary hypopituitarism, 10 with chromophobe adenoma of the pituitary and 1 with Sheehan's syndrome were all unresponsive except one with chromophobe adenoma who showed the near-the-limit responses.
Out of 12 cases of secondary hypopituitarism, 4 with craniopharyngioma, 2 with ectopic pinealoma, each one with third ventricle tumor, Schüer-Christian's disease and basal meningitis were unresponsive in both tests. One with third ventricle tumor (ependymoma) causing pubertas praecox showed normal response to both stimuli, while each one with hypothalamic glioma causing pubertas praecox (8-year-old girl), benign aqueductus stenosis (22-year-old female) showed normal response only to arginine.
Twelve cases of hypopituitarism due to unknown etiology had low responses; one of them showed near-the-limit response to arginine.
Out of 6 primary hypothyroid patients, 2 had low responses in both tests, while 3 responded normally only to arginine. One of the latter, a hypothyroidal dwarf of 17-year-old girl, had a better response to arginine after 20 days of thyroid powder therapy and restored the response to insulin after 3.5 months of therapy.
Four cases of Turner's syndrome responded lower than normal to hypoglycemia but 3 of them had normal responses to arginine.
Three of 5 cases of Cushing's syndrome, 4 with adrenal adenoma and 1 with bilateral adrenal hyperplasia, had lower responses to both tests, while 2 showed normal response only to arginine. One of the latter (adenoma) restored the response to arginine first and then to hypoglycemia after adrenalectomy.
All 6 cases of primordial dwarfs showed responses within normal range in both tests. The peak levels were higher in hypoglycemia than in arginine test in 5 cases.
Three cases of suspected, but not definitely diagnosed, anorexia nervosa (Figure 5) had low responses to insulin but normal to arginine.
Thus, the absolute values of the peak GH levels were higher in insulin test in normal subjects and 5 of 6 cases of primordial dwarfism, but higher in arginine test in all these dissociated cases.
View full abstract